Download now: Cannabis Cash

The Truth About Energy Subsidies

Fossil Fuel Gets More

Written by Nick Hodge
Posted June 19, 2012

Energy solutions should be viable without government handouts.

This we know.

It's the song of those who rail against solar and wind: “It's too expensive,” the chorus. “Just look at Solyndra,” the refrain.

They want renewables to be as cheap as fossil fuels.

I couldn't agree more.

But those same people look at me cross-eyed when I say we should expect the same of oil, coal, and gas.

Down the Rabbit Hole

The Congressional Budget Office says the U.S. federal government spent $24 billion on energy subsidies in 2011.

About $16 billion went to renewables while $2.5 billion went to fossil fuels. Don't ask me where the other $5.5 billion went — it's Congress, after all.

But the CBO only counts direct subsidies: payments or tax breaks issued directly to energy companies.

The International Energy Agency, however, defines a subsidy as “any government action that lowers the cost of fossil fuel energy production, raises the price received by energy producers, or lowers the price paid by energy consumers.”

Use that definition and the IEA says government handouts to fossil fuels dwarf what is given to renewables.

Their most recent figures show oil, coal, and gas got $312 billion in 2009 — while renewables got “only” $57 billion.

Why such a great difference?

Well, we've never had to send ships to stop Iran from blocking solar shipments through the Strait of Hormuz. The Bureau of Land Management doesn't give away millions of acres of land to drill for wind turbines. And we've never used federal dollars to clean up an efficiency spill...

You get the idea.

Most people don't consider this type of spending before they jump to the conclusion that renewables are expensive.

Yet it's precisely this type of wasteful hidden spending that's led to our woeful budget deficits.

Last time I checked, $312 billion was five times more than $57 billion.


I don't tell you this to be preachy; I'm not trying to beat the drum for renewables.

To be a great investor, you have to know the truth and invest in the reality.

I just told you the truth, but the reality is that the misconception is mainstream.

So — and I believe this is one of society's greatest current problems — you have to invest in the misconception.

What do I mean by that?

I mean that even though it's true solar energy is very close to competing with coal, we have to invest in the reality.

The reality is not many people know that.

So even though it's true that oil should be at $100 or greater in order for OPEC to invest in new fields, we have to invest in the reality that the herd thinks oil should be cheaper because of global economic woes.

And even though it's true that oil will soon be back to $100, the reality is we should wait until it sinks to $80 to buy.

In the short term, it's easy money. In the long-term, I believe it spells trouble for society and global markets, because this truth-reality dichotomy forces people who know better to invest in blatant falsehoods.

Eventually, the truth will come out.

The International Energy Agency has come out in full support of ending hidden fossil fuel subsidies.

More than a million people have signed a petition urging world leaders to end fossil fuel subsidies in conjunction with a UN meeting in Rio this week.

Just as the great energy transition will take years, so too will the phasing out of wrongheaded government giveaways.

As that happens, it's important to invest in the present while planning for the future...

So I'll still own stocks like these — even as I sit at the Renewable Energy Finance Forum today in the ballroom of the Waldorf Astoria.

I'll keep learning and spreading the truth while helping you invest in reality.

Call it like you see it,

Nick Hodge Signature

Nick Hodge

follow basic@nickchodge on Twitter

Nick is the Founder and President of the Outsider Club, and the Investment Director of the thousands-strong stock advisory, Early Advantage. Co-author of two best-selling investment books, including Energy Investing for Dummies, his insights have been shared on news programs and in magazines and newspapers around the world. For more on Nick, take a look at his editor's page.

*Follow Outsider Club on Facebook and Twitter.

Related Articles

Warren Buffett Renewable Energy Investment
Editor Jeff Siegel reveals Warren Buffett's growth strategy for energy investing.
U.S. Tariff on Chinese Solar Panels
The Commerce Department has imposed a tariff on Chinese solar panels to help stabilize prices.
Senate Gears Up for Heated Oil Subsidies Debate
Sen. Robert Menendez, the bill's chief sponsor, said Monday that the American people have become fed up with paying absurdly high gas prices while at the same time forking over taxpayer money to Big Oil in the form of subsidies, amounting to what he calls corporate welfare.
The Solar Blood is in the Street
In 1946 the first ever general purpose computer weighed 27 tons and cost over $5 million to build. I think today is the 1946 of the solar industry... and dismissing it now would be just as foolish as dismissing the computer industry back then.


Is it Safe for You to Buy Coal Stocks Yet?
Shedding Light on the Death of the Coal Industry
Investing in the Future of Solar
How to Profit Like an Investment Banker
Without the ITC, is Solar Still a Good Investment?
Will THIS Kill the Solar Industry?
The Secret Behind the Gatwick Gusher
Is the UK Running Out of Options?
Buffett Has a $4.5 Billion Stake in This Refiner
Refiners Are Safe Havens During the Low-Price Period
An OPEC Civil War Erupts
Strange Things Afoot in the House of Saud
Energy Utilities NEED the Internet of Things
Stay connected to stay on target!
The Lithium Revolution Just Got Hotter
Utility-Scale Lithium Batteries Taking Off
Metal Oil Investing 101
Meet the Oil of the 21st Century
Tesla's (NASDAQ: TSLA) Final Deathblow
The Ultimate Tesla Play